Just ran some numbers comparing dmg/stats with blood beam and my friend's damage DOES NOT compute properly at all

btw we both had 100% crit rate

My stats:

320% crit dmg

52404 m.atk

262329 hp

Her stats:

344% crit dmg

124455 m.atk

870165 hp

My average blood beam dmg ~ 200k crits

her average dmg ~ 630k crits

Blood beam calculates dmg as follows:

(0.8*m.atk + 0.045*hp) * crit dmg%

using lv 5 blood beam, ignoring the bonus dmg as it is negligible.

(Note she has lv 5 basic blood beam while I was using lv5 master blood beam)

Calculations:

my theoretical dmg:

(0.8*52404 + 262329*0.045) * 3.20

=(41923.2+11804.805)*3.2

=53728.005*3.20

=171929.616 =/=200k --> ~14% error

Conclusion, atk ratio is incorrect

Hypothesis, atk ratio is actually 100%

(52404 + 262329*0.045) * 3.20 = 205468.176 -->2.7% error this may be more accurate due to mobs unknown def/red

Her theoretical dmg

(0.8*124455 + 870165*0.045) * 3.44

(99564+ 39157.425) * 3.44

138721.425 * 3.44

=477201.702 --> 24.3% error

Reverse calculations with 630k:

630000/3.44 = 183139.534

183139 - 870165 *0.045 = 143982.1098 m.atk

If atk ratio was 80%: her m.atk would have to be 143982.1/0.8 = 179977.637

which doesn't make sense at all since her m.atk is no where near that, and even with 100% ratio, there's still 20k unaccounted m.atk

Theory: Basic blood beam has glitched mechanics that make it have a higher atk ratio at higher level skills than it should while blood beam atks in general have an 100% atk ratio (this part I've believed to be true for months as I've tested the numbers before). Using Basic blood beam level 1 shows consistent numbers therefore lv 5 may be glitched. Cannot test due to lack of sands of time. Will test on a new alt soon.

If anyone can shed light on this mystery, it would be much appreciated.

Note: I have seen her stats in a screen shot so I can confirm the numbers but she does not want me to post them.

UPDATE: Level 5 basic blood beam is indefinitely stronger than Improved and master counter parts. Though, with my numbers its 110% atk ratio

UPDATE: With an alt, numbers show atk ratio of 130% which leads me to believe the HP ratio also changed with basic blood beams level.

UPDATE: blood pact also shows some inconsistent numbers as lv 5 improved did more than basic even after crit dmg and bonus dmg. It's likely that the HP% ratio is incorrect on bp skills if atk ratio is correct. Not gonna bother testing bc I don't want to go through the math anymore as its a two variable problem.

btw we both had 100% crit rate

My stats:

320% crit dmg

52404 m.atk

262329 hp

Her stats:

344% crit dmg

124455 m.atk

870165 hp

My average blood beam dmg ~ 200k crits

her average dmg ~ 630k crits

Blood beam calculates dmg as follows:

(0.8*m.atk + 0.045*hp) * crit dmg%

using lv 5 blood beam, ignoring the bonus dmg as it is negligible.

(Note she has lv 5 basic blood beam while I was using lv5 master blood beam)

Calculations:

my theoretical dmg:

(0.8*52404 + 262329*0.045) * 3.20

=(41923.2+11804.805)*3.2

=53728.005*3.20

=171929.616 =/=200k --> ~14% error

Conclusion, atk ratio is incorrect

Hypothesis, atk ratio is actually 100%

(52404 + 262329*0.045) * 3.20 = 205468.176 -->2.7% error this may be more accurate due to mobs unknown def/red

Her theoretical dmg

(0.8*124455 + 870165*0.045) * 3.44

(99564+ 39157.425) * 3.44

138721.425 * 3.44

=477201.702 --> 24.3% error

Reverse calculations with 630k:

630000/3.44 = 183139.534

183139 - 870165 *0.045 = 143982.1098 m.atk

If atk ratio was 80%: her m.atk would have to be 143982.1/0.8 = 179977.637

which doesn't make sense at all since her m.atk is no where near that, and even with 100% ratio, there's still 20k unaccounted m.atk

Theory: Basic blood beam has glitched mechanics that make it have a higher atk ratio at higher level skills than it should while blood beam atks in general have an 100% atk ratio (this part I've believed to be true for months as I've tested the numbers before). Using Basic blood beam level 1 shows consistent numbers therefore lv 5 may be glitched. Cannot test due to lack of sands of time. Will test on a new alt soon.

If anyone can shed light on this mystery, it would be much appreciated.

Note: I have seen her stats in a screen shot so I can confirm the numbers but she does not want me to post them.

UPDATE: Level 5 basic blood beam is indefinitely stronger than Improved and master counter parts. Though, with my numbers its 110% atk ratio

UPDATE: With an alt, numbers show atk ratio of 130% which leads me to believe the HP ratio also changed with basic blood beams level.

UPDATE: blood pact also shows some inconsistent numbers as lv 5 improved did more than basic even after crit dmg and bonus dmg. It's likely that the HP% ratio is incorrect on bp skills if atk ratio is correct. Not gonna bother testing bc I don't want to go through the math anymore as its a two variable problem.

## Comment