guild siege

[R22289894]

so doesnt matter if 1 guild beats the other 1st? if both end at 0 points before reset the 1 with most BR win's?

[demmsquad]

thats what it appears to be... last week our guild and the opponents guild both reduced each others hp to zero... we reduced their guild hp to zero first before our own guild hp was zero.. their guild had higher total guild BR than us and we received the guild loss

[theghosthimself]

both receive loss if br is zero of both guilds at end of the idiotic 24 hr

[Katjuza]

its not the 24h battle time.. but this is a game for big guilds whit lots of active players... this will mean that servers be fully of big guilds..too bad smaller ones will disappear or not sing in for siege, bc its pointless. And the energy, hah, only 4 attack? borring.. energy should be reset in every 6h atleast whitout balens , ty.

[R290579301]

I am a member of the largest and strongest guild, and I can tell you this guild siege event sucks! Not only is it impossible for me to be on in time for the event (I do have to sleep), but the ridiculous restrictions/attempts make no sense. This is supposed to be a guild event that replaces Imperial Wars which replaced the previous version of guild battle. In those many more people were able to join in and have fun, because that's what playing a game is all about! Right?
Oh and one more thing... not 1 person contacted anyone in our guild for any feedback about this event. So who did you ask for feedback?

[MemoryLane]

Oh and one more thing... not 1 person contacted anyone in our guild for any feedback about this event. So who did you ask for feedback?

Feedback is gathered from the forum, tickets, surveys, and official facebook pages. Feedback is not just from R2 players, but also from ProC players, so while some of the things might seem like they've come out of left field for us, those things may have been a popular suggestion on the other wartune platform.

[R22289894]

some baatles are unfair due the kicking in of stun yesterday 1turn skill then got relic stun on me then i could do 1 skill then i got or goddes stun or the relic stun again.. and my goddesstun seems to fail everytime or work maybe once.. no fair fights anymore since they introduced the relic and goddes stun HS was more fair

[R23224943]

Feedback is gathered from the forum, tickets, surveys, and official facebook pages. Feedback is not just from R2 players, but also from ProC players, so while some of the things might seem like they've come out of left field for us, those things may have been a popular suggestion on the other wartune platform.

i'm a forum member and i am following the facebook offical groups (2 of them), following game on twitter and r2 on twiter.. the only thing i'm not apart of is the elite club on ProC and not a single 1 of those you mentioned had anything about this event on it asking for feedback etc.

[kanusti]

Feedback is gathered from the forum, tickets, surveys, and official facebook pages. Feedback is not just from R2 players, but also from ProC players, so while some of the things might seem like they've come out of left field for us, those things may have been a popular suggestion on the other wartune platform.

so a platform we dont share game whit can chose or changes it sounden crazy stupid, that ther can force changes noby, on plat from from r2, gamerocks and kong, why dont merged otr plat forms whit each other then, so w can ger more players to fight then same 20 to 30 playes that we has now in all pvp thing, ther is realy not many more then that in or cluester, but we old serv no merged to or only new serv who exist 1 to 3 months, new serv should wsait as long we has ove 2,5 year on mered.

[MemoryLane]

so a platform we dont share game whit can chose or changes it sounden crazy stupid, that ther can force changes noby, on plat from from r2, gamerocks and kong, why dont merged otr plat forms whit each other then, so w can ger more players to fight then same 20 to 30 playes that we has now in all pvp thing, ther is realy not many more then that in or cluester, but we old serv no merged to or only new serv who exist 1 to 3 months, new serv should wsait as long we has ove 2,5 year on mered.

I've said this many times before, the English version of Wartune is a partnership between R2 and ProC. And we do share the game with them, they are in our cross server brackets for all West servers, as they only release servers in one time zone.

i'm a forum member and i am following the facebook offical groups (2 of them), following game on twitter and r2 on twiter.. the only thing i'm not apart of is the elite club on ProC and not a single 1 of those you mentioned had anything about this event on it asking for feedback etc.

This patch hasn't had a survey yet. If you're talking about no feedback regarding Imperial War, there was a ton of complaints about unfair matches resulting in not being able to treasure hunt, no one wants to sit in an event for an hour, players found a way to exploit the battles, others complained about the time of day and day of week, and numerous other complaints that have been posted on the forum and in ticket for quite some time. Guild Siege only takes each person a couple of minutes, since you aren't fighting in real time refreshing doesn't break the fight, and you can hop in at any of time of day. In the devs' mind, they've solved a majority of the complaints with this event, and most of the issues people are having can be resolved by communicating and cooperating with their guildies, which will come with time.

I think one of the biggest flaws about taking feedback from players is no one ever points out what they do like about the game, nor do they post replies to feedback they just don't agree with, so sometimes feedback looks very one sided and goes in a direction we don't particularly care for.

[kanusti]

Imperial War could has ben easy fixe just make same rules on bg if 1 team a head 5k pts it is over same rule whas ther for gb but on serv and cs gb, so could easy done that on impy, new guild seig alot will never get pts in it, becuse 1 team on zxero befor ther weak up, or other def notes to strong.

[ANWB-praatpaal]

Make it so that every guild member who has logged on the day will get the rewards as well. Even if they had any change to join that event. This is fair for everyone. And also for the players who have a timezone for over 6 hours who missing most time the events.

[Xharry005x]

guilds with 210 guildies all cant take part

some players use balens to kill off hp quick so how the hell can players take part

this needs removing and massive changes made its a good idea but needs attention

[MemoryLane]

guilds with 210 guildies all cant take part

some players use balens to kill off hp quick so how the hell can players take part

this needs removing and massive changes made its a good idea but needs attention

All ears on the changes that need to be made.

If all members of a very large guild are going to participate, then there will need to be a lot of cooperation and coordination. You don't need to win fights to get contribution, and end of season rewards are based on contribution, so don't win the fights, and then everyone gets to use all of their attacks to get contribution.

[R22289894]

how about that not able to haras a player cus saying ... quest not completed