who will win ? Athena VS Aegis VS Hercules (Knight vs Knight PVP same BR and stats)

[Caballero1321]

BR again? Duh... Read only what you want.

Yes. BR, because it somehow measures our strength. I wrote my average received damage amounts.
I can't see my enemies' resistances in BG, because usually they're not from my kong server.

And the damage I receive isn't affected by enemy's resistnaces, is it?

Duh... Read only what you want.

[GrymReaper]

I apologize if I got snappy and overly defensive in any of my comments I was not feeling well yesterday (prob due to the fishbone that got stuck in my throat).

Damage from an iris against people around my br it hits usually 45-60k in a hit, it might not seem much but you stack the damage up from several hits that hurts.
As for proc. of the regen. astral, yeah it helps, but you can not guarantee it to heal you when you need it or to even give you the full 50k, the most I have ever seen it proc. is 3 times in 1 battle.
As for heals my warm spring does 120k, heal rune 63k, and aoe heal 200k. (Looked back and sorry I added an extra 17k).
Hercules in a 1 vs 1 fight dominates with nice high damage skills, but at a similar br and at 50% boost time the Herc delphic hits me for 100-160k and its other skills 50-85k.
As for fights with the mage, iris can be used to maintain a fairly high hp for once your out of sylphs at which point it can become the knight's favor if he is ready with an intercept, brutality, and an EDD.
If I left anything out please let me know .

[Caballero1321]

I apologize if I got snappy and overly defensive in any of my comments I was not feeling well yesterday (prob due to the fishbone that got stuck in my throat).

Damage from an iris against people around my br it hits usually 45-60k in a hit, it might not seem much but you stack the damage up from several hits that hurts.
As for proc. of the regen. astral, yeah it helps, but you can not guarantee it to heal you when you need it or to even give you the full 50k, the most I have ever seen it proc. is 3 times in 1 battle.
As for heals my warm spring does 120k, heal rune 63k, and aoe heal 200k. (Looked back and sorry I added an extra 17k).
Hercules in a 1 vs 1 fight dominates with nice high damage skills, but at a similar br and at 50% boost time the Herc delphic hits me for 100-160k and its other skills 50-85k.
As for fights with the mage, iris can be used to maintain a fairly high hp for once your out of sylphs at which point it can become the knight's favor if he is ready with an intercept, brutality, and an EDD.
If I left anything out please let me know .

As a mage, I love fighting Iris/Triton. I just pawn them with my Hades' upgrade
Devil's Gaze to nerf their healing, they deal me no damage when I'm in sylph form and can easily outheal them with Devour Soul skill (the one, which works similar to archer's Bloodthirsty).

[GrymReaper]

As a mage, I love fighting Iris/Triton. I just pawn them with my Hades' upgrade
Devil's Gaze to nerf their healing, they deal me no damage when I'm in sylph form and can easily outheal them with Devour Soul skill (the one, which works similar to archer's Bloodthirsty).

That depends I have tsunami so it does damage and it will get rid of your nerf on my heal , also have to remember I probably have shields to lessen the damage you do to me. The real question though is if you have a br advantage per say 12k+ more than me . If it was a fair br fight, I would say we both have a 50/50 chance of winning depending on how we utilize time and skills.

I will agree that Hades is a very good sylph depending on how you use it and the skills gained from evolving it are fantastic, but it does have some weak points.

[R26211131]

im a 260k BR knight have orange athena and 5 stars purple hercules...all sylph have advantages..in GA and GB athena will be very useful since their delphic can hit all and hard but now can be countered by using mars will so it depends on timing and runes. for CW hercules still dominate although im having a hard time facing triton which can heals very fast but they are still beatable using amnesia rune. as for aegis i didnt invest much on it but quite usefull in skytrail since can suck monster HP.

[TripleCKen]

im a 260k BR knight have orange athena and 5 stars purple hercules...all sylph have advantages..in GA and GB athena will be very useful since their delphic can hit all and hard but now can be countered by using mars will so it depends on timing and runes. for CW hercules still dominate although im having a hard time facing triton which can heals very fast but they are still beatable using amnesia rune. as for aegis i didnt invest much on it but quite usefull in skytrail since can suck monster HP.

i pmed you :P need a little help about knights

[Wraithraiser]

Hercules in a 1 vs 1 fight dominates with nice high damage skills, but at a similar br and at 50% boost time the Herc delphic hits me for 100-160k and its other skills 50-85k.
As for fights with the mage, iris can be used to maintain a fairly high hp for once your out of sylphs at which point it can become the knight's favor if he is ready with an intercept, brutality, and an EDD.
If I left anything out please let me know .

Maybe it's different at lower BRs but take me vs same BR knight from my server I have 30k mdef (almost) he has 37k and I crit him for 250k+ with delphic. There's no heals that will save you from that.

65k patk, 52% determination bonus, 42k br Herc

[GrymReaper]

Maybe it's different at lower BRs but take me vs same BR knight from my server I have 30k mdef (almost) he has 37k and I crit him for 250k+ with delphic. There's no heals that will save you from that.

65k patk, 52% determination bonus, 42k br Herc

Interesting did he use apollo shield before going in sylph, I always do this and I may make myself take a longer time to do skills so as to get the most effect out of my shield. With me extending the amount of time my shield stays I usually force the herc to delphic me while my shield is up and with my guardian angel astral most of them do not crit me. For me to reach your br 230k I would view myself with around 55k patk, 45k pdef, 40k mdef, and 220-250k hp (I could be wrong). My current stats are 44k patk, 37k pdef, 30k mdef, and 193k hp.

This may not count as a win, but I fought a 203k br knight with a 2 star purple Hercules in bg today. The only reason he won was because he stunned me for 3 turns, I had no Dryad Blessings. He beat me at his 2nd awaken, while I was stunned.

[Wraithraiser]

If you would face me in CW you'd lose even faster like that, purge is my baby rune =P

and I have lv10 guardian angel, 52% also, so 55k patk would be very weak with a non-dps sylph.

[GrymReaper]

An interesting choice, it would definitely be hard to counter the purge unless I made sure you used your other rune before I used apollo shield. As for patk we would almost be similar since I would have 10k mdef over you.

[Wraithraiser]

You forget Herc -30% mdef reduce.

[GrymReaper]

You forget Herc -30% mdef reduce.

1 word "Tsunami".

[DanteMugetsu]

the one who crits and blocks more...the end...lock thread :P

[kimwong]

1 word "Tsunami".

we have jupiter wrath that give debuff also

[mattftw]

the one who crits and blocks more...the end...lock thread :P

except for the fact that wd is better.